Welcome Page NOTICEBOARD Starts Here.... IslandKreations Simons Dream

There's room for both codes on a grand scale

Richard Hinds
October 1, 2011

LET'S take a giant leap of Andrew Demetriou's imagination. Let's pretend that some years ago the AFL won the so-called battle of the codes. That all Australians would be glued to today's AFL grand final. Nationwide viewing audience of 8 million.

The NRL version? They don't show it on TV any more. But, if the weather holds, they might get a couple of hundred along to Henson Park tomorrow.

Besides leaving a fairly large hole in the ANZ Stadium catering receipts, what would that mean based on what the two grand finals promise to provide their respective fans this weekend?

You would get: Meat Loaf, the AFL grand final's big ticket item - and just big item. Presumably, the singer will not perform on that strange Lazy Susan upon which the players' girlfriends were served up before the Brownlow Medal count. He might have lost a kilo or two since they took the food right out of his mouth, but Mr Loaf still weighs more than the average plate of spring rolls.

You would not get: Kelly Clarkson, the - and, yes, I had to look this up - ''American pop-rock singer-songwriter and actress'' who is performing at the NRL decider. Instead, the American would be idle. (Sorry, long week.) Hey, I'm not saying that the AFL dominating the landscape would be all bad.

You would get: Some ritual shirt-tugging just before the first bounce. Something that causes AFL commentators to adopt an excited tone intended to make you think you are watching a new instalment of The Rumble in the Jungle, not some harmless pushy-pushy posturing.

You would not get: Those genuinely menacing confrontations between large men who know what to do with their paws in the early moments of an NRL grand final. Which is not a vindication of on-field violence, merely a recognition of the simmering tension and physical intimidation that lurks beneath the surface.

You would get: The strange, convivial buzz that goes around the MCG on grand final day as the majority of uninterested corporates and theatre-going neutrals fill the seats of club members who were unable to get a ticket. This phenomenon was described in The Age as ''a stain on the AFL's soul''. Having again objectified women at the Brownlow, and embraced gambling companies, Demetriou was said to be delighted the game still had a soul.

You would not get: The more full-throated roar that will come from the fans who have paid for their NRL grand final tickets, not merely received them as part of a corporate entertainment package. The game, not the fans, will be sold out.

You would get: Michael Malthouse's farewell. That the veteran Collingwood coach with the militaristic bearing will attempt to end his time with the club - clearly against his wishes - by winning back-to-back flags is the AFL grand final's most interesting subplot. His fate leaves an intriguing question: Did the Pies triumph because they put their previously struggling coach on the clock? Or have they just sacked the greatest coach in their modern history?

You would not get: Ivan Cleary's farewell. Cleary will also be clearing off, leaving the Warriors for Penrith. Although, to be fair, how many people knew he was there in the first place? Not just because Auckland is the NRL's version of Mawson Base, but because Cleary is about as charismatic as a light pole.

You would get: A former Collingwood (Murray Weideman) or Geelong (Doug Wade) great handing over the premiership cup, one of the nice, symbolic touches the AFL does well on its big occasions.

You would not get: David Gallop handing the premiership trophy to the Manly players - among them Brett Stewart. Curt? Civilised? There would be plenty of binoculars trained on that moment.

You would get: The passionate chant of Coooo-llliiiing-wooood from the Magpie Army, led by their talismanic gold-jacketed cheerleader, Joffa. For some, the chant is a triumphal reminder of the club's massive supporter base. For others, a miracle only in that so many feral Pies fans can actually remember the name of the team they support.

You would not get: A pre-match rendition of the haka, to be performed in the grandstands rather than on the field. The Mad Butcher brings a strong symbolic presence to the New Zealand support - not to mention his mate John Key, sometimes known as the Prime Minister. However, I'm not sure Anthony Watmough or Tony Williams will be put off their game too greatly by a haka performed in the cheap seats by expat accountancy students from Dunedin.

Personally? May there never be a winner in the inter-code squabble. Grand final weekend merely demonstrates that this small country is lucky to have them




DEFENDER Harry O'Brien says Collingwood can draw upon its insatiable will to win as the club chases its first back-to-back premierships in 75 years.

The Magpies have not won consecutive flags since 1935-36 and for a time looked to have squandered their chance to book a second straight Grand Final berth in Friday's epic preliminary final against Hawthorn.

But as O'Brien acknowledged after the three-point come-from-behind victory, belief is often the most important ingredient in finals.

"A Grand Final is a Grand Final and we know that in elite sport, anything can happen," he said.

"But if we can just cultivate the heart that we showed in that last quarter, and bring it for four quarters, we will give ourselves the best shot at it.

"We know that the guys can improve on that (performance). Maybe it was a little like last year's Grand Final (draw) when we had so many guys down, but we still found a way.

"We have cemented a spot in the Grand Final now, that's all that matters."

Hawthorn's swarm of pressure and precision around the ground - but less so in front of goal - for three and a half quarters pushed Collingwood to the limit.

The Magpies seemed to play with less flow than normal. As a result, they were often left fumbling, second-guessing and lacking their trademark polish.

In front at every change, the Hawks pushed their lead to 21 points early in the third term before the Pies rallied.

Still, when Lance Franklin kicked an extraordinary goal at the 23-minute-mark of the last term to reclaim the lead for Hawthorn, only a massive collective effort was going to get it back.

A goal to Luke Ball - left inexplicably on his own at a stoppage two minutes later - proved the match-winner.

O'Brien said credit needed to go to Hawthorn for the manner in which they applied pressure for the majority of the night.

But he insisted several efforts from his teammates in the pulsating final term had significant impact on the result, which could so easily have gone the other way but for some inaccuracy and some late-game Hawk tiredness.

"Chris Tarrant was outstanding," O'Brien said. "You could tell what his focus was. He wants to win a premiership. Playing down back with those blokes ... I trust them with my life."

He said the move of All-Australian defender Leon Davis to attack, where he booted a critical last-term goal, also worked well.

"(Leon) has had so many critics about his finals performances and his last two finals have been outstanding," O'Brien said.

"He really did give us some essential ingredients to help us win the match."

He praised Ball's capacity to just keep giving: "I am so grateful for Luke Ball ... he is extraordinary. He is another person who some people wrote off and he epitomised what we needed to do in the last quarter."

And after a first half restricted to only six touches, and a rare below-par performance, Dale Thomas turned in what could have been the game-saving tackle in the dying seconds when Cyril Rioli looked set to stream forward.

"We know how much heart Dale has," O'Brien said. "That (effort) epitomised our final quarter, in just finding a way."

O'Brien said he could understand Mick Malthouse's emotion at the end of a draining contest, ensuring that

Malthouse will bow out as Collingwood senior coach in a Grand Final, and with possibly a fourth premiership as coach.

"He is human - everyone shows emotion," he said.

"It is not about one individual, and Mick is the first one to say that.

"(Winning the Grand Final) means so much to us all collectively because we have all worked so bloody hard during the year."




DALE "Daisy" Thomas shapes as the X-factor in terms of match-ups at the MCG tonight, with Hawthorn first-year find Isaac Smith shaping as the potential wildcard.

The question of who to play on Thomas would have occupied plenty of Hawthorn's planning at selection this week, given Thomas has rare athletic and playing gifts.

Former Western Bulldogs coach Rodney Eade acknowledges Thomas (185cm) as the nightmare match-up and nominated an unlikely candidate for consideration.

"The player with the physical attributes to play on him is Smith. He's tall (188cm) and quick, but is he defensively experienced enough?" Eade said.

"You need someone who can really run because Thomas works so hard. Smith can obviously run. We played Dylan Addison on Thomas who matched up with him athletically.

"Chance Bateman can also run, but Thomas would very quickly take him deep into Collingwood's forward line, which would cause Bateman (175cm) problems in the air.

"Paul Puopolo (173cm) is a good defender, but not strong enough in the air for Thomas.

"Grant Birchall (193cm) is the other obvious candidate.

"He has played on a wing before and done well but they may not want to move him out of defence.

"So you would look seriously at Smith, who could also hurt Thomas the other way as he showed early in the first final against Geelong."

Thomas is part of arguably the best midfield trio in the game, along with Dane Swan and Scott Pendlebury.

So what happens with the other two?

Eade believes Swan won't attract a run-with player.

"Hawthorn will most likely rely on the team defence mentality for Swan," Eade said. "In fact, they may even allow Swan and Thomas to get their possessions in the back half and midfield.

"Pendlebury is different because of his elite work around stoppages. Expect a double team of Brad Sewell and Jordan Lewis to rotate off him."

Sewell and Lewis were employed in that role in Round 22 on Chris Judd when Hawthorn beat Carlton. Judd had two disposals on Lewis in 35 minutes and five on Sewell in 28 minutes.



WHEN Collingwood's succession plan to replace Mick Malthouse with Nathan Buckley was hatched two years ago, the question, then whimsical, was asked: How would be if the Pies won back-to-back premierships?

Now, with one in the bank and another tantalisingly close, what started out as a brainstorm to keep Buckley in black and white now poses problems.

The club's success has slammed the door shut on what appeared a few obvious options Buckley might have had for coaching assistants.

And it is taken as read that Malthouse will not take up the director of coaching role that was created for him when the succession plan was hatched.

After the premiership celebrations had subsided almost a year ago Scott Burns - Buckley's fellow assistant, former teammate and the man who in 2008 succeeded him as Collingwood captain - was headhunted by West Coast and headed to Perth to help out John Worsfold.

As lately as this month it was rumoured that Burns had knocked back the offer of a two-year extension at the Eagles to keep an option open to rejoin Buckley.

Burns was interviewed for the head coach's role at Adelaide before missing out and then declared there would be no return east.

"I enjoyed the process with Adelaide but West Coast Eagles is where I want to be. I'm settled in Perth with a young family," he said on Perth radio yesterday.

Compounding that revelation was the fact that highly-rated Geelong assistant Brenton Sanderson, a teammate of Buckley's at Collingwood in 1994 who remains a close mate, got the Adelaide coaching job after he also had been touted a likely member of the Buckley coaching stable.

Only last week another Magpie topliner Mark Neeld, a Malthouse assistant for four seasons, won the the head coaching position at Melbourne and with St Kilda still to name a successor to Ross Lyon, one of the few remaining Magpie assistants Scott Waters is being mentioned as a leading contender.

Save for recently-sacked Western Bulldogs coach Rodney Eade - another likely to come under consideration for the St Kilda job - there is no one else with recent senior coaching success available.

Should Collingwood win the big one on Saturday week, it will be in the unique position of in essence sacking its back-to-back premiership coach in favour of a man who has never been in the senior role in an AFL premiership match, with virtually all the successful support staff of the past two seasons gone as well.



BANISHED for a bet, Heath Shaw is now reaping the rewards of his lonely Arizona fitness mission.

YOU see it every day in the park or at half-time in a suburban game. Dad pinpoints a pass to his eager son and then has to run to retrieve the ball after the youngster sprays the return.

It's certainly not a scenario a top AFL player would expect to experience midway through a season, alone and halfway around the world.

But this was the unplanned psychological test that bluntly asked Collingwood defender Heath Shaw whether he really wanted to be part of another finals campaign.

Shaw - banished to the club's high-altitude camp in the US as part-penance, part-preparation after an eight-game suspension for a footy bet - fought back with every bit of the grit and determination he showed on any game day.

The product of that two-week stint in Flagstaff, Arizona, is a Magpie who is 5kg lighter and tonnes wiser, one who will be an integral part of the back six against Hawthorn at the MCG on Friday night.

"It was frustrating, the situation I found myself in, but I had to work to try to get back into the team," Shaw said. "There were no guarantees.

"I sat down with 'Butters' (sports science director David Buttifant) and Mick (Malthouse) straight after (the suspension) and mapped out a program.

"At times, yeah, it was very challenging. The first four days in Arizona I was there by myself, waking up in the morning and getting yourself up to do what was set out in the program for me that day.

"We had a guide over there, but the American guy wasn't the best at kicking the footy. So it was me running and getting the footy, a bit more cardio (training) before Anthony Rocca came over to kick the footy with me.

"When you're there by yourself, you've got to get the motivation to get up and go and do your work.

"I suppose when you have that prize of a spot in that first final dangling, you want to work as hard as you can. On the way home, I was very confident I had done everything I could."

Older brother Rhyce instinctively knew what Heath was going through and made regular contact via Skype from his Sydney home.

"I spoke to Rhyce every second day," Heath said. "We're always there to support each other. He was always checking up to see how I was going.

"When you're training during the season, you ease off towards the end of the week going into a game whereas I had eight weeks (of) training every day.

"It didn't matter if I was sore by the weekend. It was just consistently trying to get the (kilometres) into my legs.

"At times I thought, 'Bloody hell, this is hard work', but I look back on it now and realise it was all worth it. I've done the hard yards and, hopefully, it will stand me in good stead.

"I've got through one game, I felt pretty good and now, hopefully, I've got two more to go and all that hard work will be worthwhile."

Buttifant said it was unusual for a player to be training at that intensity and frequency in the latter half of an AFL season.

"They don't do that much during the week anyway. So we had to be able to accommodate a program, not that you can do tackling and stuff like that, but we had to get him to load up.

"What we achieved over in Flagstaff was probably like four or five weeks back at sea level. We were able to do that in two weeks over there. So that really had a positive influence on him.

"You can always turn a negative into a positive. It was like him having another pre-season.

"We made the program very specific to him and that's why he had a lot of footy training over there.

"It was definitely difficult for him, it was pretty solid. Then when he came back we had a bit of a practice match before he played. We're pretty happy where he's at."

Not surprisingly, Shaw was sore for the first couple of days after the qualifying final win against West Coast, but the week off has freshened him up.

"It was as we all expected him to come back," fellow defender Chris Tarrant said. "And the way he has trained himself over the last six to eight weeks, the way he approached what happened to him, is pretty first-class.

"It was good to see him come back in the shape he did and I think there's only bigger and better things for him over the next week.

"I love having him back there."



Herald Sun September 13
IT is time for a gentle reminder: Collingwood has dropped just two of 23 matches this year, and recorded the highest percentage in AFL history.

Then the Magpies accounted for an in-form West Coast side despite queries over almost every one of their defenders and the absence of running machine Dale Thomas.

The reminder is necessary because the frenzy to jump off Collingwood since Saturday afternoon has been astonishing.

Yes, Geelong is a legitimate threat which inflicted both of those defeats.

But if the Pies failed to fully flex their muscles against the Eagles in their qualifying final, Mick Malthouse would still be far from panicking.

He would know the premiership is likely a race in two, and be aware Geelong is a force to be reckoned with.

But if Collingwood has some form and injury issues, it has a host of individual players still in exceptional form.


Against West Coast the performance of the back six was simply astonishing.

Nick Maxwell could scarcely have returned with more impact, Heath Shaw didn't miss a beat, and Harry O'Brien might not have lost a single one-on-one contest.

Reborn defender Leon Davis provided his career highlight with a masterful game mopping up across half back.

In the midfield Scott Pendlebury and Dane Swan shredded West Coast, and Sharrod Wellingham (three goals) finally hit top stride.

Darren Jolly bounced back from a first-quarter obliteration at the hands of Nic Naitanui to break even, and any queries over Andrew Krakouer's finals temperament evaporated.

Yet somehow, a clutch of players in individual form did not add up to collective brilliance.

Geelong might yet take apart the Pies for the third time this year, but the doom and gloom is overblown.

Surely Alan Didak will hold his place despite another modest outing, while Dale Thomas will return to add dash and goalpower.

Under the last-in, first-out policy, sub Alex Fasolo would be the favourite to make way for Thomas.

But who is pushed out if Ben Reid is fit to return from hamstring/groin problems?

Plenty have thrown up Tyson Goldsack, but he did a job on Andrew Embley on Saturday and was excellent in the Grand Final replay.

It will make for plenty of nervous players at Collingwood until next Thursday's selection.
Welcome Page
NOTICEBOARD
Starts Here....
IslandKreations
Simons Dream
JoffaMovie4Sale
Our Creed
Season 2012
VFL 2012
B+J  Show
Head-To-Head
That Chant
Nathan Buckley
You And Me 2012
UK Tour 2012
Cocky 1958?
Adios Leon
Epilepsy Vic.
Ethan
The Filth
The Season 2011
Premiers
Season 2010
Season 2009
Season 2008
10 Golden Years
The Gold Jacket
Mighty Magpies
As Time Goes By
  
Site Map